ATLAS Special Interest Group
Cultural Tourism Research Group
||Breda University of Applied Sciences
||Breda, The Netherlands
Breda University of Applied Sciences, The Netherlands
The Cultural Tourism Research Group (CTRG) has over the past 20 years undertaken nearly 40,000 visitor surveys and produced a number of publications, most of which can be found in the ATLAS publication list. In previous years a lot of work has also been carried out on the analysis of the tourism impact of the European Cultural Capitals, past and present. Specific surveys were undertaken of the cultural capitals in Rotterdam and Porto (2001), Salamanca (2002) and Sibiu (2007). A report on the Rotterdam and Porto events has already been published by ATLAS, and a draft report on Salamanca was written by a team of researchers from the University of Valladolid. A report on the long-term impacts of the Sibiu event was published in 2010 and is available from the ATLAS bookshop.
The group held Expert Meetings in Barcelona in 2003 and in Chaves, Portugal, in 2006. Both of these meetings also resulted in publications.
Details of these and other CTRG activities from Greg Richards: (email@example.com)
As the longest-running special interest group in ATLAS, we are now passing a few milestones. One of these was the 30th anniversary of the group, which we celebrated in 2021. As part of the 30th anniversary celebrations, a special track on ‘Cultural tourism re-visited’ was organised for the ATLAS Annual Conference in Prague in September 2021. This session reflected the 30 year history of the group, and reviewed trends in cultural tourism research as well as recent survey data. Some of the most recent data from the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Survey are reviewed in a paper by Carlos Fernandes and Greg Richards on Cultural tourism during the Covid-19 pandemic in Portugal. This will be published soon in the journal Tourism Culture & Communication.
In April 2022 the Symposium Tourism, Culture and Destination Development was staged in honour of Wil Munster’s retirement as Professor of Tourism and Culture at Zuyd University, Maastricht. Wil was one of the founder members of the group, and has been a regular contributor to our research programmes and meetings over the past 30 years. He was given a fittingly cultural send-off with contributions from colleagues from Maastricht and beyond. Wil himself presented an analysis of the Province of Limburg as a cultural tourism destination (in Dutch), and Michiel Flooren, Professor of Regional Development from Saxion University of Applied Sciences made a presentation on heritage as a driver for regional destination development (also in Dutch). Greg Richards linked together many of Wil’s publications in his presentation on Culture in the era of mass tourism: Challenges for managers, marketeers and researchers. Hopefully these presentations give a flavour of Wil’s important contributions to cultural tourism research over the years. We are particularly pleased that Wil’s colleagues at Zuyd University have already indicated their willingness to continue working with the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Project in future.
In terms of publications, a special issue of the Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events was produced from the joint meeting of the Cultural Tourism Group and the ATLAS Events Group. Originally scheduled to be held at Napier University in Edinburgh, the meeting was staged online because of Covid. The published contributions include a wide variety of perspectives around the theme of Festival Cities and Tourism. Most of these papers are freely available via open access.
Contents of the Special Issue on Festival Cities and Tourism
Festival cities and tourism: challenges and prospects (Open access)
Greg Richards & Maria del Pilar Leal Londoño
Understanding the influence of place on festival making and artistic production in the local urban festival context (Open access)
Danielle Lynch & Bernadette Quinn
Tensions and disputes over public space in festival cities: insights from Barcelona and Edinburgh (Open access)
David McGillivray, Alba Colombo & Xavier Villanueva
Can festivals bring social change in an ECoC city? Emotional intelligence and willingness to volunteer among university students (Open access)
Edit Kővári & Ágnes Raffay-Danyi
Food festivals as builders of the image of a tourist destination
Maria del Pilar Leal Londoño, Alexandra Georgescu-Paquin & Jordi Arcos-Pumarola
The experience of cultural festivals: evidence from Hong Kong (Open access)
Greg Richards & Brian King
Doing gender in events: feminist perspectives in critical event studies by Barbara Grabher, London, Routledge, 2022, 126 pp., £44.99 (hardback), £15.29, (eBook), ISBN 9781003121602
Marisa P. de Brito
The full meeting webinar is available to view on the ATLAS YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RC42A5Pv6ds
A number of group members also collaborated on the Cultsense publication CREATING CULTURAL UNDERSTANDING THROUGH TRAVEL. CULTSENSE CASE COLLECTION. ATLAS is a partner in this project, which seeks to develop tools for sensitizing young travellers to understand and respect better the local norms, values, beliefs and cultures of the places they visit.
As part of the ATLAS contribution to this project, the Cultural Tourism Group will be organising a SIG meeting in conjunction with the Cultsense Conference in Rotterdam on 14-15 June 2023 on the theme: “Bridging Cultures through Travel: From Theory to Practice.” Further details of the meeting will be circulated soon.
The Cultural Tourism Group will be organising a special track at the ATLAS Annual Conference in Cork entitled “From tangible to intangible cultural heritage: pathways for the future?”, convened by Greg Richards from Breda University in the Netherlands and Maria del Pilar Leal from CETT in Barcelona.
In a year marked by Covid-19, the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Group (ACTRG) faced challenges in collecting data for the long-running survey of cultural attractions and events. As tourism and culture were two of the sectors most severely impacted by the Pandemic, cultural tourism all but disappeared in 2020. Museums around the world closed and took their collections online as a way of reaching out to audiences in lockdown.
The ACTRG also adapted their research efforts to the challenges provided by the pandemic by switching to a predominantly online research strategy. The standard ATLAS questionnaire (ATLAS, 2020) was made available via Qualtrics so that visitors could be surveyed either on-site or remotely. Members of the group also conducted experiments with virtual tours of cultural tourism attractions such as the Louvre in Paris and the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, which indicated that virtual cultural tourism experiences could still be engaging, provided they were well designed.
In spite of the pandemic, however, physical cultural tourism did continue in many places, particularly in the summer of 2020. Data were collected by ATLAS partners in the Czech Republic, Albania and Portugal at a number of different sites. The low numbers of surveys collected relative to previous years underlined the effect of the pandemic on limiting visitor flows, particularly for international tourists.
In October 2020 a joint meeting was held between the ACTRG and the ATLAS Events Group on Festival Cities and Tourism. Originally planned as an offline meeting hosted by Napier University in Edinburgh, this online meeting included a wide range of presentations from researchers around the world – one of the benefits of the online format. Selected papers from this meeting are now being edited by Greg Richards and Maria del Pilar Leal Londoño for a special edition of the Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, due to be published in early 2022.
A special track on ‘Cultural tourism re-visited’ is also being organised for the ATLAS Annual Conference in Prague in September 2021. This session reflects the 30 history of the group, reviewing trends in cultural tourism research as well as recent survey data.
An updated edition of the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Bibliography was produced in April 2021. The Bibliography is now in its fifth edition, and contains over 900 references, stretching to over 60 pages. ATLAS Cultural Tourism resources, including the Cultural Tourism Bibliography, the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Survey Questionnaire and many publications from members of the group can be downloaded from the group pages at https://www.richardstourism.com/atlas-cultural-tourism-project.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group has been operating since 1991, and the main activity of the group has been the development of the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project. This project largely centres on surveys of visitors to cultural sites and events, and over the almost 30-year life span of the project we have collected more than 50,000 visitor surveys from sites on five continents.
In 2020 the main activities of the group have focussed on the development of a new wave of cultural tourism surveys. A revised version of the basic version of the cultural tourism questionnaire was developed, which kept many of the features of the previous version but added a few new elements. These included revised questions on information sources, experience outcomes and perceived authenticity. As in previous rounds of the research, the questionnaire has been designed in a modular format, which makes it easier for participants to add their own questions at different points in the questionnaire.
In contrast to previous research rounds the questionnaire will also be available in paper and digital format. A version of the survey is available on Qualtrics, so that visitors can be offered a digital version of the survey on a mobile device for face-to-face interviews or offered a survey link to complete post visit. This also provides a potential solution to the problem of interviewing visitors during the Covid-19 pandemic, because visitors can also be sent a link via email, removing the need for personal interviews. This enables research to be conducted using the mailing lists of cultural sites and events, so that even when sites are not open to the public the views of those who have visited in the past can be gathered.
As in previous years the surveys are available in different language versions. We currently have English, French and Portuguese versions in both paper and digital format. We also have different versions of these questionnaires available for interviews on site or using a mailing list. As in the past, all participating institutions will be able to use their own data for research and publication purposes. Participants can also make use of data from other sites to enable comparative research. The conditions for the use of the data are set out in a data agreement that is signed by all participants.
At the time of writing we have participating institutions from Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Ghana, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Portugal, Serbia and the UK. The largest number of participating institutions come from Portugal, where national research director Carlos Fernandes from Viana do Castelo is planning to attain national coverage with the surveys.
This year will provide a particularly challenging environment for data collection, but it should also give some very illuminating results in relation to the effects of the pandemic on cultural tourism. Tourism to cultural sites and events has been hit not only by travel restrictions, but also by closures of cultural institutions, or restrictions on visitor numbers for those that have re-opened. We are interested in gauging the extent to which restrictions and safety measures have an impact on the experience of cultural tourism, and it will be interesting to see how the survey results change over the coming months and years.
The Cultural Tourism Group has also been involved in the organisation of the Special Interest Group Meeting on Festival Cities and Cultural Tourism, planned to be held in Edinburgh in October 2020. Due to the pandemic this meeting will take place largely online, although there are plans for some members of the group to come together in Edinburgh for a panel session. This will be shared online with ATLAS members on October 22nd, together with the paper presentations from members of the Cultural Tourism and Events Groups. A publication is planned from this meeting, which will add to the already considerable range of ATLAS Cultural Tourism publications.
The group is also planning g to meet physically during a special track at the ATLAS Annual Conference in Prague in September 2021. During this meeting finalised papers from the Edinburgh meeting will be presented, together with now contributions on the theme of Festival Cities and Cultural Tourism from delegates to the Prague conference.
For more information on group activities, please see the dedicated page on the ATLAS website, or consult the resources available for download on Academia (https://independent.academia.edu/gregrichards/ATLAS-Cultural-Tourism-Project) or Researchgate (https://www.researchgate.net/project/Cultural-Tourism-4). If you are interested in joining the Cultural Tourism Research Project, please contact Greg Richards (Richards.firstname.lastname@example.org).
Following the meeting of the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group in Barcelona in 2018 (Richards 2018c), members of the group have continued to research various aspects of cultural tourism in different parts of the world.
One of the most recent studies covered cultural tourism in Albania, which has not previously been surveyed in the ATLAS project. In early 2019 Elenica Pjero from the Department of Business at University of Vlora, “Ismail Qemali” collected visitor surveys in the City of Vlora, Albania. This city on the Adriatic coast has significant cultural and heritage resources, includung many museums. A total of 381 visitors from Albania and abroad were surveyed. The majority of respondents (58%) came from the local area, with 20% coming from the rest of Albania and 22% from abroad. The majority of respondents were female, reflecting the results of previous research. The age profile also confirmed the consistent finding of ATLAS surveys that the largest age group is 20-29 (44%).
As in previous ATLAS surveys, the respondents in Vlora were most likely to agree that the ‘atmosphere’ of the destination was the most important aspect of their experience (48% strongly agree). Over 23% of respondents indicated that they normally took cultural holidays, slightly lower than other recent ATLAS studies (Richards, date). Rome (46%) was most frequently rated as a favourite cultural destination, but the Albanian respondents also tended to rate Istanbul (35%) and Athens (35%) very highly. Distant Paris was ony ranked by 29% of respondents, while in many other destinations it tends to be placed as the favourite European cultural destination.
The average length of stay was around 6 nights, with over 60% of respondents staying in hotels. The high use of hotel accommodation was perhaps one reason why the total average spending by cultural tourists was relatively high, at just under 1000 euros.
Average visit satisfaction levels were 8.25 on a 10 point scale, slightly lower than other recent ATLAS surveys. As with previous research, however, satisfaction is highest among local residents (8.43)and lowest for international visitors (7.95). Peltzer and Melkert (2008) suggest this is due to greater levels of pride in their own culture by local residents.
The ATLAS Cultural Toiurism Questionnaire is still avalable for researchers to use for surveying visitors to cultural sites and events. Participants can also access the previous ATLAS research for comparison with their own data. See www.tram-research.com/atlas for more details.
A number of publications related to the work of the Cultural Tourism Group have appeared recently, including a review of recent trends in cultural tourism research (Richards, 2018a) in the Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, and an updated version of the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Bibliography (Richards, 2018b). This work also fed into a conference staged by the Organisation of World Heritage Cities in Amsterdam in November 2018. A publication is planned from this conference, edited by Karl Luger and Matthais Ripp on World Heritage Management, urban planning and sustainable tourism.
The work of the group has also been made available in different languages, including Dutch (Richards and Bargeman, 2019) and Turkish (Richards, 2019).
Pelzer, M. and Melkert, M. (2015) ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Summary Report 2008. In Richards, G. (ed.) ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project Research Report 2008-2013. Arnhem: ATLAS, pp. 7-19.
Richards, G. (2018a) Cultural Tourism: A review of recent research and trends. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 36, 12-21. 1447-6770
Richards, G. (2018b) ATLAS Cultural Tourism Bibliography. Doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.31208.57604
Richards, G. (2018c) ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Group Report 2018 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328192715_ATLAS_Cultural_Tourism_Research_Group_Report_2018
Richards, G. and Bargeman, B. (2019) Bestaat ‘de’ cultuurtoerist nog? Vrijetijdstudies, 36(2) 37-41.
Richards, G. (2019) Kültür Turizmi: Son Araştırmalar ve Eğilimlere Dair Bir İnceleme. In Özdemir, N. and Öger, A. KÜLTÜREL MİRAS Yönetimi. Ankara: Grafiker. pp. 583-614.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group has been conducting research and organising special interest meetings on the relationship between culture and tourism since 1991, and therefore is the longest-standing ATLAS research group.
In 2018 the major activity of the group focussed on a special interest group meeting on “Participatory culture and new challenges for tourism: Responses to the challenges of mass cultural tourism” held in Barcelona.
The meeting was hosted by the Innovation and Dissemination Department (IDITUR) at Ostelea School of Tourism and Hospitality in Barcelona. A total of 29 papers were presented by the 35 participants, who were drawn from 13 different countries. The meeting aimed to address some of the pressing issues arising from the emergence of ‘mass cultural tourism’, particularly in cities with high concentrations of tangible heritage, such as Barcelona. Many papers concentrated on new cultural forms, media and spaces being occupied by tourism. One key emerging theme is the role of new media in the production and consumption of cultural tourism. Papers at the meeting included the use of web mapping technologies, Location-Aware Mobile Apps and social media to map and analyse cultural tourism and inform visitors.
Many papers also dealt with the important issue of visitor and resident engagement, because the implication of these stakeholders is vital in shaping new forms of cultural tourism and shifting cultural tourism consumption away from crowded central locations. Modes of engagement were examined in papers dealing with the production of souvenirs, the co-creation of cultural experiences with visitors (for example through creative tourism) and new times and spaces for cultural tourism. The latter included the extension of the Gaudí Route in Barcelona to Casa Vicens in the neighbourhood of Gràcia, the Palo Alto Market in Poble Nou and La Boqueria Market on the busy Ramblas.
Cultural events were also considered by a number of papers, and these have long been a means of extending and diversifying the cultural tourism product. Examples examined in the papers presented included the European Capital of Culture, Literary festivals and performances by Catalan ‘devils’ groups. Informal events, such as the development of ‘Party Tourism’ (a major challenge in popular cities such as Barcelona) and the resulting challenges of the night-time economy were also considered.
The presentations and the discussions surrounding them raised many different issues to be explored in the future work of the group. In view of the focus on the problems of cities such as Barcelona in dealing with ‘overtourism’, it is not surprising that many of these deal with the relationships between residents, tourists and culture, and how to improve and manage the experience of culture in cities.
Future activities of the group will include a publication from the Barcelona meeting, and a further meeting tentatively scheduled for the Spring of 2019 in Budapest. This may take the form of another joint meeting with the Cities Special Interest Group, following on from the successful meeting organised in Barcelona in 2013 (which resulted in the ATLAS publication Reinventing the Local in Tourism: Producing, Consuming, and Negotiating Place).
In terms of future research Melanie and Greg will be considering ways of linking the cultural tourism research to the Event Experiences Project, given the growing interest in different aspects of the cultural tourism experience. Developing comparative measures is important in understanding how different types of visitors and different forms of experience delivery and context affect the experience. Some initial work on this issue has already been conducted in Hungary and Hong.
The materials from the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project are available for download from www.tram-research.com/atlas. This includes all the questionnaires and many of the different reports and publication produced by group members.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group continues to collect data on the motivations, behaviour and experiences of cultural tourists, as it has been doing since 1991. Regular surveys of cultural tourists have been carried out in destinations around the world, revealing much about the trends in this important market.
In the past year the group launched the book Reinventing the Local in Tourism, edited by Paolo Russo and Greg Richards, which focusses on the way in which places are being transformed for and by tourism as the ‘local’ becomes the new arbiter of authenticity. The discussion about cultural tourism is also beginning to include the role of culture in the overcrowding experienced in the centre of many major tourist cities and around a number of key tourist sites worldwide. In 2018 an Expert Meeting will be staged by the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group in Barcelona looking specifically at the challenges of mass cultural tourism. This meeting will be hosted by Ostelea School of Tourism and Hospitality, Campus Barcelona, affiliated to the Lleida University and partner of EAE Business School. The event is designed to tie in to the European Year of Cultural Heritage and link to the ongoing discussion about the use, conservation and preservation of heritage in the 21st century.
Many members of the group made contributions to the UNWTO Report on Tourism and Culture Synergies (2017). This report included surveys of cultural tourism activity in UNWTO Member States, as well as a survey of leading experts in cultural tourism and cultural heritage worldwide. The results of this research indicated that cultural tourism will continue to play a key role in tourism development and marketing worldwide in future. For the future, Member States tended to prioritize product development and marketing. As a result, ‘understanding tourist behaviour’ is an important policy area, followed by diversification. Other priority areas are developing better measurement and statistics for cultural tourism, balancing promotion and protection of heritage, involving local communities and developing partnerships. Tourism experts tended to emphasise the growing importance of intangible culture and heritage in the tourism experience, and the need to develop better collaboration between the different stakeholders in cultural tourism.
Specific recommendations developed in the report include the need to:
• Create a vision for cultural tourism to link and energize stakeholders;
• Generate better information;
• Develop more specific cultural tourism policy;
• Create more targeted cultural tourism marketing activity;
• Ensure cultural protection;
• Make effective use of new technologies; and
• Foster stakeholder collaboration.
The findings of this research will be presented at the Second UNWTO/UNESCO World Conference on Tourism and Culture in Muscat in December 2017, at which discussions will be held on issues such as Tourism development and protection of cultural heritage, Culture and tourism in urban development and creativity and Exploring the Nature/Culture interface in tourism.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group continues to collect data on the motivations, behaviour and experiences of cultural tourists, as it has been doing since 1991. Regular surveys of cultural tourists have been carried out in destinations around the world, and a summary of some of the recent research was published last year by ATLAS (Richards, 2015).
More recent research was carried out by Aljoša Budović, Nikola Todorović, Jelena Apelić and Gorana Romić from the Faculty of Geography at the University of Belgrade. They studied young tourists in Belgrade, the capital of Serbia.
This research underlines the importance of culture for city tourism, as cultural attractions and events were motivations for the majority of visitors (Figure 1).
Figure 1: Travel purpose for visitors in Belgrade
Around 40% of visitors also indicated that their usual type of holiday was a cultural holiday, and a further 15% also indicated that they had engaged in creative tourism (Figure 2).
Figure 2: Usual type of holiday for visitors to Belgrade
Over a third of visitors had an occupation related to culture, underlining the strong link between work and leisure (Figure 3).
Figure 3: Is your occupation related to culture?
The results of the Serbian surveys and other ATLAS research underline the continuing importance of cultural tourism for destinations worldwide. This is also being recognised by the UNWTO, which has recently established a Tourism and Culture Department, and which has conducted a global survey of the cultural tourism market. The report, which is due to be published this autumn, reaffirms the large market share of cultural tourism, which accounts for just under 40% of all international trips, measured in terms of cultural activities. As established by earlier ATLAS research, the proportion of tourists traveling with a specific cultural motivation is much lower, around 11%.
The joint project initiated by the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Group and the Cities and National Capital Tourism Research Group in 2013 has resulted in the publication of a new book edited by Paolo Russo and Greg Richards. Reinventing the Local in Tourism: Producing, Consuming and Negotiating Place is published by Channel View, and brings together many of the papers presented in the Barcelona meeting as well as many other invited contributions. This book investigates the way localities are shaped and negotiated through tourism, and explores the emerging success of local peer-produced hospitality and tourism services which are transforming the tourist experience. Tourists are now being brought into much closer contact with locals and have new opportunities to experience the community at their destination. The book examines how these place experiences and travel-sharing arrangements have now spread globally through the mediation of ‘place experts’ who are redefining the tourism distribution system.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project has been running since 1991, and is therefore the oldest SIG still operating in the network. The group has produced a wide range of publications, including Cultural Tourism in Europe (1996), Cultural Attractions and European Tourism (2001), Cultural Tourism: Global and local perspectives (2007) and Research Methods in Cultural Tourism (2010).
The most recent Expert Meeting of the group was held in Barcelona in June 2013. This joint meeting with the City and National Capital Tourism Special Interest Group concentrated on the theme of Alternative and Creative Tourism. Papers from this meeting and addition invited contributions from scholars around the world have now been assembled in a book edited by Paolo Russo and Greg Richards. This is due to be published by Channel View in the next few months.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project was launched in 1991 with support from the European Commission. Since then over 200 researchers from 50 different countries have been involved in collecting data on the consumption of culture by tourists.
Work by Mieke Pelzer and her colleagues at Zuid University in the Netherlands has led to the compilation of a new ATLAS Cultural Tourism Report, covering the period 2008-2011. Data from eight countries are analysed in the report, which should be published later this year by ATLAS. In the meantime, research work continues, with data currently being collected by colleagues in a number of different countries.
One of the main locations in which data has been consistently collected in recent years has been the Romanian city of Sibiu, European Cultural Capital in 2007. Ilie Rotariu, together with his colleagues at the Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu, have over the years collected a vast amount of data that charts the development of cultural tourism in the city as well as monitoring the effects of the European Cultural capital event (see Richards and Rotariu, 2007, 2011).
An initial analysis of data collected in Sibiu in 2014, for example, indicate that about 20% of visitors interviewed were foreign tourists. This underlines the significant effect of the ECOC on the international image and drawing power of Sibiu as a cultural tourism destination. Almost 90% of visitors also agreed that Sibiu was a ‘cultural’ city, and over 70% indicated that the city had gained more coverage in the international media as a result of the ECOC. These initial results show that the effects of an event such as the ECOC can be long lasting, even in the face of adverse economic circumstances.
A joint meeting was held between the Cultural Tourism Group and the Capital Cities Group in Barcelona in 2013, which resulted in an e-book recently published by ATLAS. Edited by Greg Richards and Paolo Russo, the book Alternative and Creative Tourism includes 10 chapters on new directions in tourism development from a range of different countries. The production of ‘new tourism spaces’ that is evident in the case of Sibiu is also the subject of a workshop stream of the Budapest conference being organised by Paolo Russo and Greg Richards. This is a development of a discussion that emerged at the Expert Meeting organised by the group in Barcelona in 2013, where the effect of new accommodation systems such as Airbnb and Couchsurfing became evident. The workshop in Budapest will be one of the activities to lay the groundwork for a publication on New Localities in Tourism, due to be published by Channel View next year.
The Cultural Tourism Research Group is the longest standing Special Interest Group in the ATLAS network, and has now been running for over 20 years. The vast amount of research generated by the ATLAS research group and its members has recently been encapsulated in the publication of the Routledge Handbook of Cultural Tourism, edited by Melanie Smith and Greg Richards. This volume brings together 50 contributions from leading thinkers in the cultural tourism field, and reflects very clearly the major developments and issues that have emerged over the past 20 years.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism and City and National Capital Tourism Research Groups held a joint expert meeting on the theme Alternative and Creative Tourism in Barcelona on June 13-14 2013. The meeting was attended by 19 delegates from Spain, Portugal, the UK, Italy, Thailand, Hungary and the Netherlands. The meeting generate lively discussion on a range of issues, including the role of the ‘local’ in alternative and creative tourism, ‘in-between’ experiences, the rise of pop-up formats in the tourism and creative industries, city branding strategies, the development of creative quarters and creative tourism development strategies.
At the end of the meeting there was discussion on the next steps for the research groups, and also the possible publications activity for the meeting. It was agreed that the developing fields and alternative and creative tourism required more research, particularly the way in which creativity has become a strategy for producing distinction in an increasingly crowded tourist market.
There was also discussion of a number of basic principles for creative tourism. This seems to be particularly important in the face of programmes that use creativity as a label rather than a truly creative experience.
The group aims to produce an e-book of the proceedings of the meeting, which will be edited by a small group who will meet at the ATLAS annual conference in November 2013 in Malta. Authors are therefore requested to submit their full papers for publication by October 15th 2013.
There is a further conference on creative tourism planned in Porto Alegre in Brazil from October 22-23, 2013, organised by Creative Tourism Brazil. The meeting will be attended by Creative Tourism Barcelona and other members of the Creative Tourism Network.
Marjan Melkert and Mieke Pelzer of Zuid University in the Netherlands are currently working on an updated review of the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Survey research. This report will analyse the data collected in the last few years by members of the ATLAS project, bringing the research more up to date. The previous report dates from 2004, so an update is long overdue. It is hoped to be able to distribute this to ATLAS members in the next few months.
Much of the work of the Cultural Tourism Group over the past year has been directed to producing the Routledge Handbook of Cultural Tourism, edited by Melanie Smith and Greg Richards. A number of the members of the group contributed pieces to this mammoth reference work, which contains 50 chapters on all aspects of cultural tourism research. The Handbook is due to be published later this year (http://www.routledge.com/books/details/9780415523516/)
The work reproduced in the Handbook clearly shows the development of cultural tourism research over the past 20 years, and underlines the contribution made by the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project to advancing the research agenda. When the project was launched in 1990, cultural tourism was an emerging, but under-researched field. This changed rapidly during the 1990s as governments and researchers began to pay more attention to the rapid growth of cultural tourism demand and the development of new cultural resources directed at tourists. The emergence of cultural tourism as a form of ‘mass tourism’ during the ‘naughties’ was linked to increasing diversification as destinations increasingly tried to distinguish their cultural tourism products from the growing range of competitors. This in turn led to the ‘serial reproduction’ of culture for tourism, as the search for distinction often led to the adoption of similar strategies, particularly linked to iconic buildings and mega-events.
Recent years have therefore seen a critical turn in cultural tourism research which is widely reflected in the contributions to the Handbook. In many cases, however, this has led to a relative neglect of the empirical evidence necessary to underpin such critiques. There is a need to renew and revitalise the cultural tourism research programme to take account of the new realities of cultural tourism, as well as incorporating new research methods in cultural tourism. This is one of the challenges for the future work of the group.
In the meantime, attention is being paid to the treasure house of data in the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Project. Greg Richards and Andries van der Ark have been analysing the 45,000 surveys in the database to identify trends in cultural consumption. The initial findings of this work indicate that the ‘normal’ relationships between cultural capital and cultural consumption are inverted in the case of cultural tourism, with those individuals with high levels of cultural capital exhibiting more conservative consumption patterns than other tourists.
The ATLAS surveys are also being used as the basis for events research by members of the ATLAS Events Special Interest Group. One area of joint research that has been continuing for some time has been the analysis of cities hosting the European Capital of Culture (see separate report). One particular area in which event research and cultural tourism research have converged has been in the Romanian city of Sibiu. This city has been the focus of an ATLAS research project since 2001. Project leader Ilie Rotariu from the Lucian Blaga University has been surveying residents and tourists in the city with the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Questionnaire for over a decade. To date, almost 6000 surveys have been completed, providing a fascinating glimpse into the development of the cultural tourism market over time.
The research clearly shows that a major boost was provided to cultural tourism by the ECOC in 2007, when almost twice as many foreign tourists visited the city. But also following the ECOC there was a qualitative shift in tourism demand, with more international visitors, higher per capita spending and more visits to cultural attractions. The quality of visitor experience also increased as the product was upgraded for the ECOC, with renovation of cultural attractions and new hotels. The overall result was a shift towards ‘quality’ tourism, with a resulting growth in per capita spend. This trend is clearly visible in the quality ratings given by visitors, which have climbed by nearly 16% over the past decade. Interestingly the peak quality scores were given not in the ECOC year itself (2007), but immediately thereafter.
A number of reports have been published on the Sibiu study, and these are available from the ATLAS bookshop or from www.connectcp.org/gregrichards.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Project has now been running for 20 years, and it is still generating key insights into the development of the cultural tourism market worldwide. The main activities of the project have focussed on the collection of data on the motivations and behaviour of cultural tourists in destinations and cultural sites around the world. To date, almost 50,000 visitor surveys have been contributed to the ATLAS database.
In 2010 and 2011 ATLAS members continued to monitor a range of sites, mainly in Europe. Data were collected from the city of Sibiu (Romania) as part of a long-term monitoring project looking at culture-led regeneration in the city. A report was recently released covering the 10 year project, which was also launched by Professor Ilie Rotariu, the Rector of Lucian Blaga University and the Major of Sibiu. The report is now available to download (see below). Other areas in which datra has been collected recently include The Netherlands, Poland, Latvia, Serbia Hungary. The basic questionnaires for the ATLAS research can be downloaded from www.tram-research.com/atlas, where survey instructions and templates can also be found. The site also includes links to a wide range of ATLAS research publications.
Over the next few months Karolina Buczkowska of the University School of Physical Education in Poznan, Poland will be helping to prepare a review of the first 20 years of ATLAS research. This will include not just an analysis of major trends from the ATLAS data, but also a review of more qualitative developments in the field. This year the ATLAS data also helped to contribute to the Council of Europe review of the European Cultural Routes, the results of which they will publish shortly.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Group (CTRG) has now been running for 18 years, and was the first ATLAS SIG to be established. In that time the group has carried out a wide range of research and dissemination activities, mainly centered around the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project.
Launched in 1992, the cultural tourism research has to date generated over 40,000 surveys of visitors to cultural sites around the world. The project utilizes a standard questionnaire form, which participants can download from the project website (www.tram-research.com/atlas) in a variety of languages. This research has generated a number of key publications on cultural tourism, most of which are available from the ATLAS bookshop.
Over the years, however, there has been increasing attention for the relative lack of qualitative research in this area, and this led the group to propose the publication of a research monograph reviewing the state of the art in cultural tourism research methods and presenting a number of new directions, particularly in qualitative and ethnographic research approaches. This volume: Cultural Tourism Research Methods, edited by Greg Richard sand Wil Munsters, has recently been published by CABI (http://bookshop.cabi.org/). The volume contains 17 chapters, covering methods such as surveys, mystery tourist visits, visitor tracking, grand tour narratives, collage, researcher-created video, photo-based interviews, ethnographic and actor-network approaches. It provides a practical guide on how to conduct research as well as a discussion and evaluation of the methods. The contributors include many authors who have collaborated with the ATLAS research programme over the years, and the case studies range from Europe to Asia, Australia and Latin America. The first chapter of the book can be downloaded from the CABI website.
The Cyprus conference in 2010 will provide the group with an important opportunity to review activities for the future. One proposal which will be considered is a project on the relationship between tourism and creativity, which is being developed in partnership with the European Cultural Tourism Network. A number of CTRG members have already expressed an interest in this project, and an ECTN representative has been invited to Cyprus to continue the discussions about further developments. The outcome of these discussions are likely to have an important impact on the future direction of the ATLAS survey programme, but in the meantime many ATLAS members are continuing to use the existing survey instrument to gather data on cultural tourism around the world. Participants in 2009 and 2010 have included partners from Cyprus, Latvia and India
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Project is now in its 16th year, and to date has generated over 40,000 visitor surveys at cultural sites around the world. In 2007 the group continued to develop its research activities and publications. You can find more details on the project website: www.tram-research.com/atlas.
A number of changes have been made to the research programme for 2007. The latest version of the questionnaire has been modularised to make it easier for participants to adapt the basic questionnaire to their own research needs. This also makes it easier to use the questionnaire as a part of research assignments for students.
The 2007 questionnaire is currently available in English, French, German, Greek, Italian, Latvian, Portuguese, Serbian, Spanish and Turkish. Other languages will be added as these become available. As in previous years, different versions will also be produced for different world regions, including Africa, Asia, Australasia, Europe, North America and Latin America.
In previous years each round of surveys has been restricted to a single calendar year. However, we have now decided to extend the timescale of the research so that the current programme will run with the same survey format for at least three years. This will allow partners more flexibility in the timing of their surveys, and also give them more time to build the surveys in their own research and student assignments.
The group is also developing a qualitative research strand to run alongside the quantitative visitor surveys. There will be a special session on this at the group meeting during the Annual Conference in Viana.
The group had a very successful Expert Meeting at Chaves in Portugal in November 2006. The theme of the meeting was Cultural Tourism and Identity, which attracted papers from all corners of the world. The meeting was hosted by the Universidade de Trás-os-Montes e Alto Douro, and was excellently organised by Xerado Pereiro and Veronika Nelly. The proceedings of the meeting will be published by UTAD and launched at the ATLAS Conference in Viana in September.
Other group publications have also appeared during the past year. The papers presented at the Barcelona group meeting In 2003 have now been published by Haworth Press in the volume 'Culture Tourism: Global and Local Perspectives'. A link to this volume can be found on the publications page of the ATLAS website. The report of the 2004 ATLAS Cultural Tourism Surveys has also now been published, and is available from ATLAS (www.atlas-euro.org).
Portuguese-speaking members of the group may also be interested in the publication from the Universidade do Algarve 'O Evento FCNC 2005 e o Turismo', which analyses the Portuguese Capital of Culture event held in Faro in 2005. This study was based on the ATLAS methodology which was also used to study previous Capitals of Culture, and therefore provides interesting comparative data.
ATLAS has also established a collaboration with European Cities Marketing, a network of 140 cities across 30 European countries. The aim of the collaboration is to partner cities and research institutions in the development of cultural tourism and other visitor-related research projects. A presentation on the ATLAS research was made at their Annual meeting in Barcelona in May.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism is celebrating its 15th birthday in 2006 with its 6th round of cultural visitor surveys and an expert meeting in Chaves, Portugal. During the past 15 years, the group has conducted over 35,000 visitor surveys at cultural attractions around the world, and built up the most comprehensive global database on cultural tourism.
Following the visitor surveys carried out in 1992, 1997, 2000, 2001 and 2004, 30 group members from 20 countries in Europe, Africa, Asia, Australasia and America are undertaking new studies in 2006. Participation in the research is facilitated by a standard questionnaire which can be downloaded in different language versions from the website (www.tram-research.com/atlas). The 2006 questionnaire has a special focus on the visitor experience, testing out some of the dimensions put forward by Pine and Gilmore in their book 'The Experience Economy'.
The 2006 team has many new participants, including researchers from Mongolia, Latvia, Kenya and South Africa, as well as many Cultural Tourism Research addicts who are now participating in their fourth or even fifth round of surveys. Particular thanks should go to our local coordinators who help to organise networks of universities to collect data on a national basis. Carlos Fernandes has done a particularly good job in Portugal, where thousands of surveys collected over the past 10 years have helped to create a detailed picture of cultural tourism consumption across the country.
Our research partners are also very resourceful when it comes to adapting the basic surveys to their specific needs, and also in finding applications for the research which can generate funding. In the Netherlands, Wil Munsters has used the surveys as the basis for a 'Cultural Destination Experience Audit', which is proving very popular with Dutch cities. Esther Binkhorst is hoping to develop a similar tool using the surveys in her home town of Sitges (Catalunya).
The ATLAS data is rapidly establishing itself as a leading source of cultural tourism information for academics and practitioners alike. The data were used to provide information for the recent UNWTO/European Tourism Commission report on 'City Tourism and Culture', as well as the European Commission evaluation of the European Cultural Capitals programme.
Members of the group have also been active in spreading the results of the research through publications and conference presentations. On the project website you can find publications from Georg Stadlmann on Innsbruck, Austria, Xerardo Pereiro on Trás-os-Montes in Northern Portugal, Elisabeth Kastenholz,
Maria João Carneiro, and Celeste Eusébio on segments of cultural tourists visiting Coimbra, Portugal, Patricia de Camargo on a crafts fair in Curitiba, Brazil, Zafer Oter and Osman Ozdogan on Ephesus in Turkey and Timo Toivonen's paper comparing omnivorousness in cultural tourism in different countries.
The group has produced a large number of publications over the years, including Cultural Tourism in Europe (1996), Cultural Attractions and European Tourism (2001), a study of the Cultural Capitals in Rotterdam and Porto (2002) and Salamanca (2003).
The next publication to appear will be the volume entitled Cultural Tourism: Global and Local Perspectives, to be published by Haworth Press later this year. This collection of the papers presented at the Expert Meeting held in Barcelona in 2003 includes contributions on the nature of cultural tourism, cultural tourist behaviour, cultural tourism in cities and in emerging areas such as South Africa.
The next meeting of the group on 'Cultural Tourism: Negotiating Identities' will be held at the Universidade de Trás-Os-Montes e Alto Douro in Chaves, Portugal on October 5-7. This meeting has already attracted a record number of abstracts, and promises to offer an exciting mixture of academic debate and cultural experiences.
One of the issues to be discussed in Chaves will be the future form of the research programme. The idea of running a continuous programme of surveys to build up an even more comprehensive and flexible database has been put forward by Timo Toivonen. There are also plans being made to collaborate with European Cities Tourism, to help city tourist offices monitor their cultural tourism demand, and to provide more logistical support for conducting the surveys.
The Cultural Tourism Research Group is the oldest Special Interest Group in the ATLAS network, having been operating since its initial meeting in Germany in 1992. The group now has 62 members from 23 countries.
In 2004/05 the group has been busy with a fourth round of data for its cultural tourism research project. Having started with the (then) 12 member states of the EU in 1992, the latest research involved 35 members from 25 countries. This time there was considerably more participation from outside Europe, with Africa and Latin America being notable additions to the research.
The fieldwork yielded a total of over 13,000 completed visitor questionnaires at different types of cultural sites. The project was ably supported by Celia Queiros, a graduate of the Polytechnic Institute of Viana do Castelo in Portugal. She worked extremely hard during 2004 to develop a centralized management and data collection systems for the project, using the website www.geocities.com/atlasproject2004. This site contains all the different language versions of the questionnaires used in the surveys as well as full implementation instructions. This allowed the different participants to work more or less independently and vastly increased the amount of data that could be processed.
The results of the 2004 surveys indicate that the general structure of the cultural tourism market has changed relatively little over the past decade. The cultural visitors tend to be highly educated, relatively wealthy individuals with a high level of cultural capital. Because of rising education levels, cultural holidays seem to be more important for this particular group. One of the key changes in the market, particularly in Europe, has been the increasingly important role of budget airlines in driving the growth of city breaks. This has also raised the use of Internet to book both travel and accommodation.
Due to its wide coverage and longitudinal comparisons, the ATLAS surveys have now become one of the most important sources of cultural tourism research information. Each project participant received a complete set of the global data, allowing them to produce comparative studies. The latest CTRG publication, Cultural Tourism: Global and Local Perspectives was also completed. This will be published by Haworth Press in 2007.
The ATLAS Cultural Tourism Project website has been updated and is now available on www.tram-research.com/atlas
If you have any new items for the website, including publications from the project, please forward them to me and we will put them on the site. Future publications and research activities will be on the agenda at the forthcoming project meeting during the ATLAS conference in Barcelona.
Cultural tourism has been identified as one of the most rapidly growing areas of global tourism demand. The importance of this market has created a need for information on the characteristics, behaviour and motivations of cultural tourists. Over the past decade, the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Programme has monitored this market through visitor surveys and studies of cultural tourism policies and suppliers. Successive surveys have illustrated how rapidly this market is developing, underlining the need for regular research.
In 2004, ATLAS is launching a new Cultural Tourism Research Project, with over 50 participating institutions from Europe, Africa, Asia, Australasia and Latin America. The depth and geographic extent of the surveys will be significantly greater than in past.
The aim of the 2004 research will be to analyse the motivations, socio-demographic profiles, consumption patterns and destination images of cultural tourists.
Read more at a joint ATLAS and INTERARTS website: http://www.geocities.com/atlasproject2004
The first expert meeting organised by the ATLAS Cultural Tourism Research Group was attended by 20 participants from 7 different countries, who had intensive discussions about the current state of cultural tourism over three days of sessions. The presentations were of a very high standard and generated lively and thoughtful exchanges. The concentrated nature of the expert meeting format allowed ideas to be developed and elaborated throughout the course of the meeting.
It is very difficult to summarise the wide-ranging contributions to the meeting, so this report concentrates instead on the major issues raised and the actions that may be taken by the group in future.
The discussions during the meeting displayed some level of continuity with previous work by the group and by other researchers. For example the issue of authenticity in cultural tourism was discussed in a number of papers, as were conflicts over the 'ownership' of culture and the shifting boundaries of culture and economy.
In addition to these continuities, some differences also emerged. For the first time ever in a meeting about cultural tourism, there was no mention at all of the definition of cultural tourism. This was a very positive point for the meeting itself, since endless discussions about the definition of culture were avoided. But perhaps it also points to a degree of maturity in this emerging research field, as people perhaps no longer feel they need to define each facet of their study object. There was some development of the debate about the nature of the study of cultural tourism, however, with the debate seeming to move away from the cultural 'content' of tourism (high culture, popular culture, etc.) towards the 'context' in which culture is consumed (as part of a process of learning about a city, as a process of distinction, repeat visitors versus first time visitors, etc). In terms of cultural tourism policy, a similar shift can perhaps also be identified in the emergence of 'cultural programming' of cities in place of cultural planning.
Another emerging area of work involves the concept of 'place' - which indicates that the study of cultural tourism is following the spatial turn in the social sciences.
Closely linked to place is the idea of distinctiveness, which seems to have been posed as an alternative to authenticity in some cases. Participation is also an emerging concept which seems closely linked to place - since the participation is usually the residents of a particular location.
When one looks at what might be distinct about places, it usually comes down to some aspect of the local, and the nature of 'everyday life'. This is an interesting development, in the sense that tourism has usually been linked to the 'extraordinary', which has led people to ignore the role of routine and ordinariness in tourism behaviour. Perhaps when 'everyday life' becomes 'culture', it suddenly becomes more interesting not only to consume, but also to study.
But the problem of distinctiveness is perhaps more complex than it might seem on the surface. What for example is the relationship between the terms distinction, difference, novelty and change? Are people looking for distinctiveness rather than difference? Are they looking for new distinctions, or simply more distinct experiences? One of the areas that might be worth examining is the extent to which cultural tourism is related to the collection of experiences as building blocks of identity (usually treated as a characteristic of the visited, rather than the visitor).
This also raises an interesting question of choice regarding the cultural experiences people are consuming. To what extent are people selecting specific experiences that fit a particular set of personal choices (or a lifestyle) or are they consuming a range of experiences offered by a particular place? In this regard, the concept of placelessness is also important, since the whole idea of placelessness is intimately linked to choice. The papers presented at the meeting seemed to reflect two different approaches to place and placelessness:
- A sense of loss for 'real' places (which links to authenticity)
- An increasing desire for non-places (everyday life, Mcdonaldisation)
Your degree of choice radically effects your reaction to these situations of placelessness, because if you have the choice to move, then non-places can be treated playfully. If you don't have that luxury, then these non-places become the raw material from which you need to create a sense of place. There is an interesting sidelight on this problem in Barcelona with the policy of creating 'hard plazas'. These are classic non-places, in the sense that they are stripped of even the most basic markers of place. In reality, however, the people who are forced to use them (because of their lack of mobility) are busy creating place markers of their own, through graffiti, through lounging around, through events. It is also interesting to speculate how this process in turn makes these placeless spaces into desirable places for the tourist.
It therefore seems that notions such as place and placelessness, distinction and difference, culture and identity are all closely linked in the cultural tourism system. Unravelling these different aspects of the cultural tourism experience may well require new approaches to the study of cultural tourists.
Scale of enquiry and methodology
One of the big changes in the study of cultural tourism compared with 10 years ago is the extent to which problems are posed in terms of the local and the global. This is understandable in terms of the pervasive influence of studies of globalisation. The problem is that we are usually operating at one level or the other - there is rarely a link between the two.
In the past, this was a potential advantage of the ATLAS cultural tourism programme - by tackling localised case studies within a wider European or global structure, the peculiarities of the local and the convergence of the global become more visible.
One of the problems with the current ATLAS framework is perhaps the reliance on survey methodology. This has fallen out of fashion with many analysts because of the limitations of quantitative data and the apparent richness of qualitative data. The problem is that without a rigorous basis for comparison, we lose one of the most basic strengths of quantitative research.
This is why we need to look for new methodologies that can link the global and the local as well combining the advantages of the quantitative and qualitative traditions. Q methodology (now being used by the backpacker research group) may be a way of mapping the socially-constructed field of 'cultural tourism' as well.
A number of areas for future work were also identified by the meeting participants.
In terms of research, it was generally agreed that the following areas would be of interest to group members:
- The tourist perspective on cultural tourism, particularly in terms of allowing the tourists themselves to make their own interpretation of the meaning of their consumption.
- There should be more attention paid to the planning systems within which cultural tourism functions (both from a cultural and a tourism perspective). The content/context dichotomy of the cultural tourism experience could be examined in terms of the embeddedness and institutional thickness of systems in different locations.
- More evaluation of the outcomes of policy interventions is also needed. There is scope for the study of the qualitative and quantitative impacts of events and programmes, such as the EU structural funds, in the field of cultural tourism.
- In the face of globalisation, the local is remarkably persistent. Although cultural tourism is often accused of being a harbinger of modernisation and the destruction of culture, homogenisation still seems a long way off in most destinations. More attention needs to be paid to the structures and practices underpinning the local, and how these articulate with the tourist search for distinctiveness, difference and novelty.
- The spatial consequences of cultural tourism could be explored through the study of cultural quarters and 'ethnoscapes'.
- The issue of the management of cultural tourism has been relatively under-researched in the past. More attention could be paid to the management of cultural tourism sites and the emerging networks of cultural tourism development and promotion, which join the public, private and voluntary sectors.
- There is a need to pay more attention to the special circumstances prevailing in different areas of the world. In particular there was a call to undertake specific research on cultural tourism in Africa, perhaps in conjunction with the ATLAS Africa group. Such studies could look at issues of globalisation and localisation, for example through the influence of former colonial links on current tourism patterns.
- More attention needs to be paid to the different categories of actors in the cultural tourism system - the tourists, residents, policy-makers, suppliers, etc. At present we take the distinctions between these groups for granted, whereas these are often indistinct groups.
- Links can also be made with other ATLAS SIGs, including the gastronomy group and the festivals group. There was also a call for more research on the role of souvenirs in cultural tourism, which links to work undertaken in the EUROTEX project.
These areas need to be drawn into a research plan for the group, which identifies the key priorities for research and puts forward the means to achieve these.
Research strategies and tools
It was clear from the wide range of initiatives being undertaken by the meeting participants and others in this field that there is a need for some degree of co-ordination and networking in the field. In this regard, Greg Richards presented the plans of ATLAS, Interarts and ArtBase for a 'Culture and Tourism Exchange' (CATEX), which would seek to support networking between and within the cultural and tourism sectors on an international basis. It is hoped to develop this proposal further in the coming months.
In addition it was suggested that the development of standardised survey tools or qualitative research instruments would be of value to the group. These might be able to be used by students to conduct comparative research in different countries. A series of comparative case studies might also be developed by students for their dissertations. A system of data exchange for such projects might be one function of CATEX.
Jordi Juan suggested that a link might be made with the UNESCO Chairs in cultural tourism. They have a network, although they have no specific funding for research.
There was considerable discussion of the publication options for the group, both in terms of the papers presented at the meeting and in the longer term. In the short term it was agreed to publish the papers via ATLAS.
In the longer term, members of the group are already collaborating with the volumes being edited by Melanie Smith and David Leslie. It was also suggested that the group should work on producing an Encyclopaedia of Cultural Tourism (this idea has already had some interest from CABI).
There was also felt to be a need for a text in the area of urban regeneration and cultural tourism.
There may also be some scope for more specialised publications, for example in the area of the European capitals of culture.
Julie Wilson suggested that the group should start compiling a bibliography, which would be useful for all members as well as providing source material for publications. There was also a suggestion that it would be useful to compile a list of current research projects among members to increase the flow of information.
Some delegates also pointed out the need for course development in the area of cultural tourism. There seems to be a particular need in Africa and Latin America at the moment. There was a suggestion that this might be linked to the Winter University concept.
It might also be useful to bring academics and practitioners together to discuss issues of mutual importance.
It was suggested that current projects being undertaken by group members should be documented, so that CTRG members could learn more about each others' current research.
It was agreed that future 'expert meetings' would be of value to the group. There are already plans for two conferences involving the group (August 2004 in Barcelona and October 2004 in Finland), so it might be a good idea to arrange at least one meeting in conjunction with these events. For the longer term, Xerado Pereiro indicated that his university in Portugal would be willing to host future meetings.
There will also be a short meeting of CTRG members present at the Naples conference in April 2004. This meeting will focus on the development of the research plan for the group.